No on California Propositions 41 & 42

Prop 41 & Prop 42: New  requirements and prohibitions on state taxes.

We’re addressing these two billionaire-funded initiatives together because they are supported by many of the same groups and people and they have several things in common.  We hope to counter misinformation about them

First, who are their funders and their supporters.

Prop 42 Major Backers and Supporters:

  • Reform California (right-wing political group supporting such efforts as Gavin Newsom recall, Voter ID initiative)
  • Building a Better California (received $57 million from Sergey Brin, a Google co-founder and Trump donor).
  • Peace Officers Research Association of California
  • California Professional Firefighters
  • State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
No on Propositions 41 and 42. White text on orange and green block background. Image credit: 350 Bay Area Action.

Prop 41 Major Backers and Supporters:

  • “Californians for a More Transparent and Effective Government” through Building a Better California, which has received $57 million from Google co-founder, and Trump donor, Sergey Brin. It and prop 42 are in fact supported by several billionaires.
  • Reform California

Both of these initiatives were put on the ballot in an attempt to nullify prop 40 (“the billionaire tax”), but each one goes further in its own way, potentially making it harder for California to raise revenue for essential needs, now and in the future. Whether or not you support Prop 40, we strongly urge everyone to vote against Billionaire-funded laws on how Californians take care of our State’s needs. 

 

Deeper Dives on 41 and 42. Beyond the spin.

 Proposition 42 – does 3 major things (2 talked about here) 

  1. Outlaws new taxes on most assets not including real estate
  2. Outlaws retroactive taxes going back before a tax goes into effect (this is sneakier than it appears).

Thing 1. While the proponents would stir up fear around retirement accounts being taxed, there are a couple of things that are useful to understand. This initiative does not change what you now owe when you cash out your retirement accounts. Retirement income is treated as just that, income. Incentives are built-in to help people retire by giving them more money to invest (paying the taxes later) or letting them invest and grow tax-free (by paying taxes upfront and then getting tax-free interest, as in a Roth account). But both the IRS and California will tax it either before or after it enters the account. This law does not change that. 

Prop 42 says that California cannot make New taxes on assets, such as vehicles, art, jewelry and collectibles, business assets and yes retirement accounts.  Prop 40 aside (the billionaire tax), California is not very likely to create significant (or any) new taxes on retirement accounts, though technically it has the legal ability, as do most states. If legislators raid people’s retirement accounts, they will soon be out of their jobs. Prop 41 is about Prop 40; it’s a trick using a lot of fear, while hiding the real aim of this measure.  We are in a time of budget constraints and federal attacks and we must not let billionaires use scare-tactics to pass new comprehensive tax law constraints. Let our legislators do their jobs.

Thing 2. Outlawing retroactive taxes – This removal of “look-back” provisions is also aimed at Prop 40, but could further protect billionaires from paying their share. Many tax bills have at least a short “look-back” period where the tax goes back to before the law starts. This may sound unfair, but aims at the opposite. There is a time-lag between when a bill is debated or passed, and when it goes into effect. A look-back can help to ensure that those with means don’t shuffle their finances to avoid paying the tax (potentially leaving everyone else with the burden).

Prop 41 is a Constitutional Amendment that makes it harder for any taxes to qualify for the California ballot, now and for the future. Ballot measures are primarily used to fund public services, often with support from major legislators and/or governors.

The law, first and foremost, is again aimed at Prop 40 through prohibiting any tax that is excluded from the State’s spending cap. What does this mean? There are special taxes, earmarked for special purposes, that are not part of the State’s general spending cap. Ballot measures may raise money for things such as education, schools, state parks, healthcare, roads and public transit, etc. They don’t always pass, but when a need is perceived by enough people, they may. Some of these may not be designed under the State’s spending cap. If this law passes it would force all such money raised to be included as part of the State’s spending cap. This means we as voters will never again (unless we later vote to amend this) be allowed to spend beyond the cap, even if we agree to put more money in through a special measure for something we know we need. We can vote No on any individual proposition now, and in fact fewer special taxes have won than lost. But we would be giving away our right to weigh each ballot measure according to its design and our needs. Don’t let billionaires dictate our tax laws.

Another big part of the Prop 41 puzzle is new audit requirements for ballot propositions long-before they reach the ballot (once they get 25% of needed signatures), and on-going audits. The first audit will be published before the measure is voted on. These are conducted by the State’s Auditor, and this law requires the Auditor to recommend spending cuts of 10% annually! Most propositions already do have built-in oversight, often through independent oversight bodies. Taxpayers will pay for the audits either from the State’s general fund if the measure doesn’t pass, or from the measure’s funds if it does. The published audits could make it difficult to vote Yes on anything, if we have to read that the measure can and should be cutting its spending before it’s even gone into effect, implying potential waste. We believe this is aimed at making it more difficult to get measures on the ballot and get them passed.

Rebecca Medcalf